With a total reported budget of just $800 (most of which likely went to a single camera and one actor), it shouldn’t work. But it does. At least enough to land a spot on Variety’s Top 13 Horror Films of 2024 — right alongside movies with actual marketing budgets and VFX departments.
So we hit play. And then we spiraled.
📹 The Premise: Pranks, Psychopaths, and a Brick
Milk and Serial follows two best friends, Milk and Seven, who run a YouTube prank channel. Their content? The chaotic, kind-of-messed-up kind that gets clicks, concern, and maybe the occasional cease and desist. On the surface, their biggest crime is bad taste and overcommitment. But beneath it?
Something much darker is brewing.
The story opens with a birthday prank that goes wrong — but that’s just the start. The more we watch, the more it becomes clear that Milk has layered this “prank” with an ulterior motive. By the halfway mark, it’s no longer a question of surprise party antics. It’s a serial killer origin story hidden inside a YouTube channel.
🎥 The Format: Found-Footage with Intent
Shot entirely through handheld party cams, hidden setups, and “prank cam” perspectives, the lo-fi style isn’t a byproduct of the budget — it’s baked into the DNA of the film. The shaky lens, the grainy lighting, the out-of-focus moments? All intentional. The whole movie operates like something you'd find deep in a late-night YouTube rabbit hole.
And that’s both its charm and its challenge. While the aesthetic supports the story, it also makes for a visually difficult viewing experience. If Blair Witch-style cinematography makes you seasick, you’ve been warned.
But buried in that handheld chaos? A well-crafted villain who plays the long game.
✅ What Makes It Work
• Milk is genuinely terrifying. The character delivers chilling monologues to the camera, deadpan confessions, and manipulations that feel too real.
• The writing is shockingly tight. For a film that looks like it was shot on a dare, the script pulls off slow-burn tension with actual payoff.
• It goes there. The plot includes staged shootings, fake breakups, dark web livestreaming, and manipulation so deep it becomes existential.
• The format gets in its own way. The shaky cam is immersive but exhausting. At times, it pulls you out of the narrative more than it pulls you in.
• Some of the emotional beats fall flat. We wanted more resentment, more tension between Milk and Seven before things got violent.
• The ending is ambiguous. We’re still debating whether that final gunshot was a suicide or just a double-tap.
💸 Should It Have a Bigger Budget?
Absolutely. There’s a better movie inside this movie, waiting to be reborn with a real camera crew, a lighting setup, and maybe three more actors. We’d love to see this as a fully realized indie-horror project — maybe Creep meets Host, with the unsettling charisma turned up even further.
🎯 The Verdict
We’ve seen worse films with a million-dollar marketing campaign. Milk and Serial is flawed, but it’s memorable. It proves that when the writing lands and the villain is well-developed, you don’t need a studio to scare the hell out of people.
Cade: 5/10 — “Great concept, but I need a tripod.”
Kit: 3.5/10 — “Fantastic villain. Needed more meat around the bone. Trash-adjacent — but high-functioning trash.”
📺 Where to Watch
It’s free on YouTube.
It’s under an hour.
It’s the kind of weird you bring to group chat.
🍿 Pair This Movie With...
• Snack: A questionable red velvet cupcake
• Drink: Anything with ice cubes and existential dread
• Activity: Text your best friend and tell them you trust them... probably
🎤 We’re Cade & Kit. Real People. Real Reviews.
And if you ever catch us talking to a brick on camera… just run.
🎧 Spotify
📸 Instagram
info@CadeandKit.com
Publication: I'm Here With Magazine
